Skip to main content

Best Gluten Free Brownie Mix- Taste Test Update

Gluten Free Brownie Mix Taste Test - The Winner


And the winner is...

Steve and I decided to do a taste test. Our goal? Finding the best tasting gluten-free brownie from a mix. Our criteria? A brownie so abundant in chocolaty goodness it would fool a gluten eater. Steve is the brownie baker in the family, so he was in on this project from the start. 

I had him at, What if...

For the sake of simplicity we chose to compare the three gluten-free mixes readily available at our local markets: Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Brownie Mix, Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix, and The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix.

We were most familiar with The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix as it was the first gluten-free mix we tried when we gave up gluten five years ago. It gave us hope. The will to live. Gooey, chocolate goodness.

I suppose I should mention here, in the spirit of full disclosure, we always add extra semi-sweet chocolate chips into our bar and cookie recipes; even if the recipe or mix might not call for chips; and if a recipe or mix does call for chips, we double it. We like our brownies decadent. Life is short.
So, let's get to it.

We began this experiment with Pamela's. Here are our notes.


Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix

Pros::

Honey and molasses for sweetening - a plus for those limiting sugar intake.

I used cold coffee for the liquid (as directed on the package for a mocha flavor - nice option!) and I thought the balance of chocolate to coffee flavor was perfect, and overall, not too sweet.

The brownies rose high, and had more of a cake-like texture than I expect in a brownie, but I didn't hold that against them. They looked like a true brownie when I took them out of the oven.

Cons::

The mix (as is) needs a smaller pan than my favorite large Chicago Metallic pan.

Baked at sea level [read: humid] the texture was more cakey than chewy-gooey. Because of this, Steve voted these down.

Update note: For some reason, these brownies seem to bake even better in a drier climate. Because we are at high altitude now, I upped the oven temperature to 375 degrees F- as Pamela's suggests for high altitude- and they came out perfect.



Pros::

The Bob's Red Mill mix has a nice look to the packaging; very appealing.

I liked the use of turbinado sugar in the mix, and the Ghiardelli cocoa.

Cons::

An in-between amount of batter and I had to choose between my favorite large brownie pan and the smaller Pyrex; I chose to stretch it and used the big pan, so the brownies were thin. If I were to do it again, I'd try a muffin tin.

The texture was good and slightly chewy, not gooey, but passable.

The flavor was just okay. I'm not a fan of bean flours. There was something missing.

Our overall impression was, well. These taste a tad "gluten-free" and we would not bother making them as a real treat. We doubted a gluten-eater would be enamored.



Pros::

Lots of batter for the buck- enough so that I could use my favorite large brownie pan.

I also appreciate the preparation tip on the bag to line the pan with foil and grease it. This makes clean-up: done.

Hands down the best texture and mouth feel. A perfect balance of chewy and gooey.

We both believe even gluten-eaters would be impressed with these brownies. They look, feel, and taste like a normal brownie living in a gluten filled world.

Steve's number one choice, no contest.

Cons::

No real complaints from me. Pretty darn good. Fudgy.

The winner?

The original winner from December 2005 is pictured above in all its glorious chocolate radiance. It's The Gluten Free Pantry Chocolate Truffle Brownie Mix.


Update 2008:

We now have a two new faves, Dear Gluten-Free Reader. Pamela's Irresistible Chocolate Brownie Mix and Namaste Brownie Mix. We kick 'em up with extras.


Kick Up Your Mix::
  • Substitute the water with coffee, coconut milk, or a safe vanilla non-dairy milk
  • Add a cup of shredded sweetened coconut
  • Add more chips- we add a cup of semi-sweet chocolate chips or try a cup of gluten-free white chocolate chips or even peanut butter chips
  • Add a half cup peanuts, macadamia nuts, pecans or walnuts
  • Go Chunky style- add raisins and chips and peanuts, or Almond Joy style with coconut and toasted almonds
  • With the additions above, you may need to use a larger brownie pan


And if, by any chance, you're feeling up to baking a brownie from scratch...see my divinely delicious dark chocolate brownie recipe.

TRENDING

Gluten-Free Baking Tips + Substitutions

Need wheat-free gluten-free baking tips? Help is Here. Here's what works- and what doesn't- in quirky Gluten-Free Baking and Substitution Land. From Karina, Gluten-Free Goddess®. Baking Substitutions for Wheat-Free, Gluten-Free and More Notes on GF Flours: Gluten-free non-wheat flours generally fall into three basic weights- light starch, all-purpose medium, or heavier whole grain. A blend of medium and heavy flours with some starch mixed in to lighten, tenderize, and help bind the batter or dough works best, and tastes best (too much starch can result in a gummy texture). Light, starchy GF flours include sweet rice flour, white rice flour, and the ubiquitous gluten-free starches- tapioca starch, cornstarch, potato starch (NOT potato flour, which is whole different animal) and arrowroot starch. Medium flours are akin to 'all purpose flour'- these include sorghum flour, certified gluten-free oat flour, and superfine brown rice flour. If you cannot find sorg

Sweet Potato Black Bean Enchiladas

YES PLEASE.  This award winning budget-friendly Santa Fe inspired vegetarian enchilada recipe is one of those happy accidents that springs from a burst of creative imagination. Or rumbling hunger. In that what-have-we-got-in-the-pantry sort of panic. I was craving the soft and spicy comfort of enchiladas one windy spring night back in 2003, and I had none of the usual suspects on hand (no chicken, or beef, no pinto beans).  But! I had one lovely mother of a sweet potato.  A can of organic black beans.  Some roasted green chiles.  One lonely lime.  And your intrepid Mamacita-Goddess at large thought, Hmmm. Why not? Deliciousness ensued. These wrapped little gems are soft and creamy and a little bit spicy- Just like a certain cook , my point-scoring husband wisecracks. It's the yams, I tell him. Er, sweet potato. I can never tell the difference. Can you? In the end, it doesn't matter.  What matters is how it tastes. And darling, these are so mucho scrumptiou

Gluten-Free Goddess Flourless Chocolate Cake

Ah, flourless chocolate cake. The perfect rich dessert. Forgive the hyperbole. But I just can't help it. This is rich, sexy chocolate deliciousness on a plate. And such an easy recipe, especially if you use a food processor to do the work. Serve this to non-gluten-free folks with no apologies. None. Zip. Nada. And for gluten-free folks? Hand out seconds (we deserve it, don't we?). And the best part is- the recipe is inherently gluten-free and wheat-free. Always has been. No substitutions. No funny stuff. This is the same flourless chocolate cake I've been making for decades. It never contained flour. The only thing I've tweaked post-celiac diagnosis is adding more coffee and vanilla. Just because. And PS: See below why I make this recipe in a food processor- thanks to Bobby Flay. Karina xo

Gluten-Free Goddess Lemon Yogurt Cake

Luscious Lemon Cake So  I've been jonesing for a cake laced with citrus- not too sweet and not too light. A cake with character and heft.  Something akin to a lovely simple cake I remember liking as a child, a store bought bakery cake called Louisiana Ring made by Freihofer's. The cake featured a hint of orange. The day I decided to bake, I did not have oranges in the pantry- but I did have some lemons, organic Greek yogurt, and plenty of blanched almond flour.  And this simple home baked lemon cake was born.  In time for Spring. Love, Karina xo

Gluten-Free Goddess Pasta Frittata with Kale

An Italian Classic - Updated. Today I offer you a simple recipe spun from the magic of leftover gluten-free spaghetti and eggs- a creamy, light frittata. Perfect for the weekend. Or when you're simply too tired to cook. Or you have nothing in the fridge but a carton of eggs, half a bag of kale salad and last night's leftover cooked spaghetti. It's one of those intuitive, spontaneous recipes I've pulled out of thin air, so many times. For dairy-free folks, the "cheese" pictured in this version was a vegan "mozzarella" (my current favorite is Vegan Gourmet). But if you prefer using dairy- select one or two of your favorite Italian organic cheeses. I've also made this yummy dish using goat cheese (and roasted red peppers!), and another time I tried a blend of fresh mozzarella and shaved Parmesan. It's a very versatile recipe. Celebrate Spring. Have fun with it! XOX Karina

Gluten-Free Goddess Quinoa Breakfast Cake

Gluten-Free Goddess Quinoa Breakfast Cake. Tender and sweet. There are some days (okay, I confess) I eat a brownie for breakfast. And not just a brownie. A tender, dark chocolate melt-in-your-mouth  Gluten-Free Goddess Brownie . A brownie to delight in. A brownie to savor. A brownie even gluten-eaters would covet. Is it a nutritious choice? Um, probably not. Except as food for the soul. And sometimes, let’s face it. The soul needs chocolate.  But this morning there was a trendy new box of quinoa flakes perched on the kitchen counter. And a fresh bag of plump seedless raisins nearby. I leaned against the counter's edge and sipped my morning cup of java. I started daydreaming about cake. Maybe a carrot cake. With cinnamon. I knew what I had to do. Quinoa was calling to me. Quinoa (pronounced keen-wa) is a fab ancient faux grain (it's actually a fruit seed) that is high in protein and naturally gluten-free, and lucky for cereal lovers, it turns out quinoa flakes make a satisfying

Gluten-Free Goddess Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

A classic cookie made gluten-free. I suppose you could argue that one oatmeal cookie recipe is enough. I mean, how many oatmeal cookie recipes does a person need? To this I answer, at least two. Why? Well, first you have one with raisins (my oatmeal raisin cookies here ). Raisins give oatmeal cookies that old school chewy sneaky nutrition boost. They're old fashioned and comfy cozy. Kinda like spending one of those Saturday afternoons at your Aunt Martha's house, chillin'. Watching Mr. Rogers and laying on the floor with a pile of coloring books. Coloring outside the lines with a beat up box of Crayolas. Wishing the silver crayon was more than a lonely nub. And right at that nub lamenting moment she'd bring you a plate of cookies. Truth is, I never had an Aunt Martha. But I did have a chain smoking platinum blond babysitter who liked martinis a little too much. Or maybe it was gin and tonic. There was ice in the glass. If I was lucky enough to scro